I read this New York Magazine article a while ago, and I highly recommend it if you have kids, or are thinking about having kids, or are thinking about not having kids. If you've decided you're definitely not going to have kids, and you are one of those people who think that your decision makes you smarter and more responsible and better looking than people who have kids, you can skip it because it will only make you feel smug, and that doesn't look good on anyone.
Here's the thing: I'm surprised that people are surprised by the research on happiness and child rearing. Parenting is so many things, such a mixed bag of highs and lows, but I would never say that having children made me happy.
Knitting makes me happy. Day hikes make me happy. Driving a car alone at night with music playing loud makes me happy. Getting drunk in a bar with a jukebox and playing pool with good friends makes me happy. Watching action films of the 1980s with my dad makes me happy. Ben and Jerry's in general makes me happy.
Taking care of my kids doesn't make me happy. It's an absolute struggle on a daily basis to try and do the right thing and not treat the older one like shit because she's high strung and demanding and doesn't sleep well and when she's in the bathtub cannot stop herself from squirting the baby in the face with water from the extra peri bottle from my birth kit. Sometimes locating the nonviolent communicator inside yourself, the emotionally literate calm talker, the information giver and the soother and so help me even the one that can ignore the stuff that really ought to be ignored, is like trying to squeeze that last drop of water from a wrung-out cloth. It hurts your hands, and you keep twisting and nothing's coming but you need that drop, you need it right now, you need it 10 minutes ago before Big Kid shut the baby's finger in the door and you had to turn the handle and open it to get her finger out again. How is that in any way related to happiness?
There's the joy, of course. I know it makes some people without children incredibly angry when parents say this (and unfortunately it's not a universal experience) but I had no idea what it meant to love someone before I had my first child. I remember getting Big Kid home from the hospital and for the first moment having some quiet time by myself to hold her, and in the absence of hospital stress and birth fatigue, suddenly feeling this bottomless pit open up and yawn inside me. My breath caught in my throat; nothing anyone had said could have prepared me for that moment, for how terrifying my love for her would be. It was overwhelming. I held her tiny fluttering body in my hands and sobbed. And with the second one, a friend of mine said it best: "When I had my second daughter I was disheartened to realize that I can't just kill myself if something happens to one of them."
It gets a little easier to cope with that love as they get older, and surlier. They start to become people of the world a little more, and spend less time in Tir na nog. They start saying really insane and wonderful things that you mean to write down but almost always forget, and at some point they can play chess and make a sandwich and things are kind of settled and pleasurable before the teen years hit, or so I'm told.
There's a lot of joy in there. There is transformation and depth of understanding. There's figuring out how to get out of your own way and practicing kindness and learning to earn forgiveness and experiencing the wonderful magic of children themselves. I feel grateful to know my girls, who are both funny and ridiculous and full of life.
But, as one psychologist says in the article, “They’re a huge source of joy, but they turn every other source of joy to shit.”
It's true. You trade in your big "I" Individual card for a while and get used to someone wrecking your nice things and keeping you awake at night and trying to sit on your lap while you're pooping and yelling at you when you try to listen to NPR on Saturday morning. In exchange you get to royally screw up raising someone who you would give both of your kidneys to.
The other day I was struggling to hold it together, was exhausted by the endless repetitions of "Mama? Mama? Mama? Mama?" and the conflicting needs that took too long to fulfill and the impatience of both children and myself and finally I was involved with some kind of chore and making headway (was it making the beds? washing dishes? using the bathroom?), when I heard relative quiet in the living room. I looked out at the girls and saw this:
Big Kid had put an audiobook on her CD player, put the headphones on Baby and given her a cup of milk out of the fridge. She had done it to make her happy, because she loves her.
That's the joy.
You get to witness their lives. You get to love them.
That's all. That's everything.