Oh, Christmas.
You used to be so uncomplicated.
I remember so much of you from my early childhood: the twisted red and "white" (it was dough, folks...dough's not truly white unless there's a serious problem) candy cane cookies my mom made, the Care Bears Christmas record my sister and I put on while we ran around like maniacs in the living room, the cookies we left for Santa that I somehow always understood my father ate, the morning I came downstairs into the quiet mystical darkness of a tree-lit room to find ROLLER! SKATES! next to my stocking, the time I expected a bicycle and didn't get one and I cried and then my dad rolled the black and yellow BMX out from the other room and it was perfect (although I would develop the notion that bees were attracted to it and would, at some point, remove the yellow padding to avoid being swarmed by them).
Christmas!
So much tied up into the sweet cinnamon bow of it, nestled into its felted wool tip toe, wrapped up in its shining crinkling paper heart.
I had good parents, and we had more than enough to go around, and so my Christmases were wonderful.
And then I grew older and the game of it all became something more like greed, or rather something very, very much like it, and then I grew older again and ashamed and it became something different altogether: a chance to mark the subtle, or not so subtle, changes in the landscape of my family.
It was a chance to dust off old stupid affectionate taunts, to note the comforting familiarity of the knicknacks and the manger scenes, the plastic baby Jesus that always fit so perfectly in the crook of the goose girl's arm. It was the time to let the gifts mount up next to me while I drank my sparkling cider too fast and saw, loved to see, how we could not let my grandfather open a book or he would never finish opening his gifts, the gifts that always made him so uncomfortable and grateful at the same time.
There were more of us for a long while, burbling Buddha babes in ridiculous red and green one piece suits, newly minted fiancees and, once, a brand new bride and groom.
And then there were fewer. First the bachelor great uncle who sat in the back room watching the football game died, and his was the first and only corpse I have ever seen. And then my grandfathers, beloved, beloved, and never again. And we lost marriages. And dogs.
The scene has changed, too, as the family celebration moved from a grandparents' house to an aunt and uncle's, and finally to my own parents', and as dear ones have moved from one house to another or away and back again or just away for good.
And we ourselves have grown taller or fatter or both. The child who screeched the Care Bears songs has two coarse colorless hairs that peek out from the crown of her head and two screeching children of her own.
Now I'm making that childhood Christmas for someone else, and it has muddled me horribly. I'm grappling with how to help my kids make some meaning out of this season that, obviously, means a very great deal to a great number of people, in good and bad ways.
My husband and I settled on some ground rules early on in our lives as parents. We buy our children some, but not a lot. Overwhelmingly, our purchases are made from locally owned businesses. We eschew large quantities of sweets. We strive for traditions of family and community connection, not consumption. So that's fine. Or rather it had been.
Up until this year we hadn't bothered with the Santa myth, in part because it made me very uncomfortable to actively build up a falsehood for my child, and in part because it seemed fine to let her make whatever assumptions she wanted to. She woke up to a filled stocking and gifts under the tree. Ta da! Then last year she said that Santa brought gifts to other children but not to her. We hadn't told her explicitly that Santa filled her stocking, but we hadn't told her explicitly that Santa wasn't real, either. I felt awful. So this year we have stepped into the Santa myth more fully, because she wants to have that. We've left windows open in this construct, though, so a little light of play shines on all of it.
As part of the whole thing I encouraged her to write a letter to him, mostly to practice her writing, which was incredibly sweet. Unfortunately, as part of the letter I reminded her that she can ask Santa for a gift. And unfortunately, the gift she asked for is something we can't realistically afford to buy her. I found myself in a serious conundrum.
What do you do when "Santa" is not going to bring what a child specifically asked him for?
This problem sits right at the heart of my muddle over the whole season. To try and distill the essence of my discomfort, my feeling is that as a society we are trapped in an incredibly toxic economic situation where we have to spend a lot of money that, in many cases, we don't even have just to keep everything in motion. So in a bad economy, and a good economy, the "right" thing to do is spend a lot of money. That is also very much the wrong thing to do, because many people don't have much extra income to spend and debt is a life destroying force. There is nothing good about it.
This isn't even touching on my concerns about fair compensation for labor, the funneling of wealth out of communities and the human health and environmental impacts of extraction, manufacturing, use of a given product during its lifetime and ultimate disposal.
But sitting there with her little eyes lit up is my kid, who just wants to experience Christmas.
I had to be realistic and make the determination that we aren't going to buy that doll. It's beyond our budget, and, this is essential, she has far too many dolls.
That's how I found myself today carefully discussing with my daughter what Santa might bring for her. I told her that what Santa wanted for her was a nice surprise on Christmas morning. And I told her that Santa doesn't want her to feel overwhelmed with her toys and games. He just wants her to have warm feelings on a special day. So he will fill her stocking (she made sure to confirm that it will be full), but whatever else he brings will be an elf-made surprise. Honestly, she was pretty okay with that. That made sense to her: Santa wants to stop by and sprinkle her life with some magic and wonder. He doesn't want to check off a shopping list.
I think that squares us up. As far as gift giving goes, the rules stay, and they stay simple: don't overspend, welcome the experiences and don't chase the stuff quite so much. The kids get a few toys that we feel comfortable with from cradle to grave.
For next year, I've learned that we need to steer the kids away from specific requests from Santa. Santa will be Magical Surprise Man. If they want to ask for something specific, they need to ask us so that we can tell them "no" up front if we need to, and give them a reason.
By taking the burden of wish fulfillment off of poor Santa, we've also made room for some really exciting possibilities. Without the checklist (did anyone else used to go through the Sears toy calatog obsessively as a child?) Santa and his elves can, you know, make stuff.*
Fun!
See, I am fun. I do not obsess over Christmas all day long. I have been experiencing a significant shift in my worldview, my moral compass, my relationship with money and material goods and my parenting philosophy, all at once, around the whole Christmas deal. It has not been particularly merry. Actually, that's not true. It's been a growth process. Those always kind of suck, but then you're really glad they happened. It's called disequilibrium and the more you experience it in your life, the less likely you are to be a jerkwad. Changing your cognitive structures is a good thing. Word.
Now! Stuff. Because it's Christmas and I feel like I'm constantly shopping for something even though we're doing it "simple" style.

That shit looks so seasonal. Big Kid made the bean heart in preschool prior to Thanksgiving and it makes me happy happy. The tablecloth is pretty groovy, too.
This is super groovy:

I found him lurking in the antique mall and he was crazy, ludicrously inexpensive. Cheap. I felt kind of guilty buying him for so little, because he is fancy, and I have to guess that the vendor didn't know how fancy he is. But, now he is ours. I was hoping to sneak him past the kid for Christmas love but that didn't work out so he was Highly Unusual Unexpected Toy Purchase dragon.
Now I feel all weird for sharing my overwrought thought process around mundane topics.
Go watch this. It's adorable.
*Have you noticed that in recent Santa movies the "workshop" is basically a factory floor with marked, licensed toys rolling by on conveyor belts? That is some f-ed up shizz right there.